The short answer
An illegal throw is a throw that breaks a rule of play. Exactly which throws count depends on the rules you are playing. A casual round may follow house rules agreed by the group. A sanctioned event follows the PDGA rulebook, which is the authority for competitive play. The cases below are the ones that come up most often.
Stance and lie violations
Your lie is the spot where your disc came to rest. In PDGA play, you mark it with a mini marker disc. You throw from behind your lie. Throwing from in front of the marker, or stepping past it before the disc has been released, is a common illegal throw.
Circle 1 putting rules
Circle 1 is the area within 10 meters (about 33 feet) of the basket. Inside it, you must keep your balance behind your lie until the disc has been released. Stepping or falling forward through the lie before release is a violation. The PDGA rulebook has the exact wording, and it is worth reading before you play a sanctioned round, since putting is where most stance disputes happen.
Turn order
In general, the player farthest from the basket throws first. Throwing out of turn is a rules issue, but the outcome depends on the rules you are playing. Check with the group, or the rulebook for a sanctioned event, before you decide what happens.
Safety and the group ahead
Do not throw until the group ahead is clear of the landing zone and out of your line of flight. A throw into the group ahead is a safety problem first and a rules problem second. Most rule sets and most courses expect you to wait until the area is clear.
Equipment
Discs must be legal for the event you are playing. In sanctioned play, discs must meet the PDGA’s equipment standards, and altered discs are not allowed. Check your discs against the current rules before you enter an event, not on the first tee.
What happens after an illegal throw
The penalty depends on the rule that was broken and the rules set you are playing under. In a casual round, the group may simply agree to replay the throw. Under PDGA rules, the rulebook sets the penalty. Do not assume a penalty from one set of rules applies to another.
Rules versus etiquette
Some habits feel like rules but are etiquette. Keeping quiet during someone else’s putt, clapping for a good shot, and returning a lost disc are all part of the game’s culture. Breaking them does not usually carry a penalty, but they are still part of how the game works.
If you are unsure whether a throw is legal, ask the group before you throw, not after. For the putting stance that comes up most often, the putting form guide explains how to stay behind your lie. For a short answer to the question of which throw is most useful, see what is the best throw in disc golf.